Jewish people must retain agency over their stories, identity and narratives
“Progressive Jewish publications such as the Forward have criticized Project Esther for its lack of genuine Jewish representation. Unable to garner substantial Jewish support, the initiative is a plan developed by Christian nationalists for Christian nationalist goals. Ben Lorber, senior research analyst at Political Research Associates, describes the initiative as focused on ‘repressing progressive movements under the guise of protecting Jews’ rather than addressing the systemic roots of antisemitism. Lorber notes that Project Esther conflates legitimate criticisms of Israel with antisemitism in order to dismantle progressive movements.”